Imagine for a moment, that you're the boyfriend of a home baker who hates roses and loves puns. You came up with a brilliant birthday gift for your cheese-obsessed Wisconsinite (a cheese making kit from Wisconsin). But, you feel like something's missing: a birthday bouquet. She's forbidden you from sending her flowers. What do you get her? Well, you could get her flowers with the roots still attached arguing that plants don't count as flowers. You could get her seeds to grow her own flowers. You could send the flowers anyway hoping that she really wanted them and just told you not to buy them. Or, you could go the Stranger Than Fiction route and, wouldn't you know, come up with the perfect gift! Send flours instead of flowers. (Side note: he's made me watch both Stranger Than Fiction and Chocolat, and I'm fairly certain he's subtly planting hints for my next career change.)
Now, I knew to check my mailbox, expecting flowers. Instead, I found a big rectangular box that weighed about 30 pounds. When I opened it, I found a postcard with this note "They're not roses, but who doesn't love flours for their birthday?" Under the card were two more boxes, each full of little bags of flour! Every bag was a different flour: blue cornmeal, yellow cornmeal, brown rice flour, barley flour, buckwheat flour, millet flour, oat flour, rye flour, and spelt flour. The idea was that the flours would challenge me to be creative in the kitchen and try new recipes.
One year later, I've only finished 2 bags of flour: rye and barley. I was very pleased with both and found that they were great to use in baked goods for flavor and moisture. I've even purchased more barley and rye flour in the bulk section at Whole Foods. The buckwheat flour has about 1/2 a crepe recipe-worth left in the bag. I've used a little oat flour, millet flour, spelt flour, and blue cornmeal. C always brings up the spelt flour thinking that it's getting neglected (it hasn't been neglected, it's just the biggest, most colorful bag). I've hardly touched the brown rice flour because it's very tricky to use without xanthan gum, which I prefer to omit. I was also having a hard time using the oat flour, but I think I've finally discovered that the key is using it in cookies. The yellow corn flour has yet to be opened--but I blame C for buying "masa harina," not realizing we already had the English version.
Some of my creativity got the better of me and there were a few real flops. On the flip side, I found a few truly great recipes that I never would have tried before C's challenge. Others were fun to experiment with and lead to yummy treats. Those are the recipes I'll share with you today.
Barley Flour:
Banana Muffin Tops with Steel-Cut Oats from The Kitchn
Prepared as muffins. Subbed cinnamon for the nutmeg. Go buy bananas right now. Make these as soon as they are ripe. Feel free to stir in up to 1 cup of shredded veges (zucchini, beets, and/or carrots). Make these now, thank me later.
Lemon Blueberry Pancakes from Food52
Used Barley flour for the whole wheat flour and divided the all-purpose into 50:50 all-purpose and whole wheat pastry flours. Used only 1.5 tbsp. butter, added an egg, and used 3/4 cup buttermilk. Thinned to the right consistency with milk before cooking.
Buttermilk Barley Bread from Food52
Made as stated in the recipe. The bread was very soft and perfect for sandwiches. I did not like it as toast because it was a little too moist/dense to get crispy. I was a bit underwhelmed for the effort it took to find rolled barley. If I made it again, I'd probably just use oatmeal. Needs a little more flavor, but I'm not sure what.
Blue Cornmeal:
Fresh Corn Cornbread with Lemon Thyme Crumble
This was really quite good. I made this around the time of our chili cook-off. They disappeared quickly. This recipe is from the Dahlia Baking Company cookbook (p. 98). Here's an adaptation called "Raspberry Cornbread Loaf with Cornmeal Oat Crumble" from Flavor the Moments (I haven't tried this version). I can't find the lemon thyme recipe on the internet. It's very good. While the recipe called for yellow cornmeal, I used blue. I also used normal thyme and added extra lemon zest. I made muffins instead of a loaf.
Brown Rice Flour:
I haven't made anything with just brown rice flour. The reason for that is that rice flour doesn't do a whole lot. It is the trickiest of the gluten free flours to use. However, I've used it in the following recipes:
Spelt Pancakes from Bon Appetit (under spelt)
Three Flour Pizza Crust from What Liberty Ate (under buckwheat)
Buckwheat Flour:
Three Flour Pizza Crust from What Liberty Ate
This pizza dough uses wheat, buckwheat, and rice flour. It has a nice flavor and texture. Fair warning: the dough tares easily. I've substituted the rice flour for all-purpose, and it still tares. I might use bread flour next time. I have only made the crust and added my own toppings.
Buckwheat Crepes from Food and Wine
We fell in love with this recipe and have eaten a lot of crepes since we found it. That means a lot because I was terrified of crepes because I'd heard they were very challenging to make. Luckily C is a crepe master and taught me well. Uses 1:1 all-purpose to buckwheat flour. I have only made crepes, but have used savory and sweet fillings. This is also the reason we did a Nutella challenge and have 4 different Nutella-like spreads at home.
Millet Flour:
Five Grain Flour Blend (used here in Cream Waffles)
This flour blend is from the book Good to the Grain by Kim Boyce. Also uses oat, barley, rye and whole wheat. The blend of grains worked really well! I did not like the waffle recipe because (a) it used a ridiculous amount of cream and C was complaining about his arteries, and (b) it tasted egg-y. When I tried the flour blend in another waffle recipe, I had the same egg-y problem. Maybe I just don't like waffles, or, maybe it has something to do with the waffle iron being brand new. I'll have to give the flour blend a try in muffins or something else.
Hmm? I guess I opened the millet just for this recipe. I haven't used it for anything else yet. That will have to change soon!
Oat Flour:
Flour's Famous Banana Bread
Substituted all-purpose flour with oat flour. Was very good fresh, but not very good left over. A combination of flours is probably the route to go for a quick-bread.
Healthier Toll House Chocolate Chip Cookies
I made this recipe, but substituted oat flour for the blended rolled oats (I weighed out the correct amount of oats and used that weight in oat flour). These cookies are unique, but not in a bad way. I would prefer them with a little more butter, but they're nice for a lighter, nuttier alternative. I'll try adding oat flour to my normal recipe and see how it goes.
Oatmeal Pancakes from Smitten Kitchen
These oatmeal pancakes use both oat flour and cooked oatmeal. They taste like (surprise!) oatmeal! I used steel cut oatmeal which gave it some texture. I think it would be really tasty and texturally pleasing with coconut. I halved the recipe but used 2 tbsp. butter since I only had skim milk. I used molasses, not honey.
Rye Flour:
Cinnamon Swirl Bread from SoNo Baking Company Cookbook
This is an amazing bread to eat fresh or as french toast. I accidentally swapped the amounts of wheat and rye flour. That gave it a stronger rye flour but was very good. I got compliments on the bread from my qualifying exam committee. You can check out a version made by The Urban Baker.
Most of my non-rye bread inspiration came from Apt. 2B Baking Co. In addition to beautiful pictures and fun stories, you'll find a bunch of great recipes on the site that inspired:
Rhubarb and Sorrel Scones
Peach Galettes and Strawberry Balsamic Galettes
Spelt Flour:
Spelt Pancakes from Bon Appetit
I made these for C the first time he visited me in St. Louis after receiving all the flour. This recipe uses spelt, rice, and oat flours. We both agreed that they are pretty darn good for whole grains!
Wheat-Free Velvety Beet Brownies
I made the recipe but used 1 whole beet, 4 oz. of chocolate, 1/2 tsp. salt, 3/4 cup white sugar + 1/4 cup brown sugar, left out the baking powder, and added a third egg. Ok, so maybe I really didn't make this recipe. Now, I don't know why I keep trying beets. I think it's time to give it up. I can taste them and they make things a little too "earthy." However, using spelt flour in brownies seemed to be just fine. I'm going to try making spelt brownies without beets next time I make brownies. Why not make them a little more nutritious with any flour other than all-purpose?
So, I'm now one year into my every-flour-under-the-sun challenge. What have I learned? I can make a lot more than just rye bread with rye flour. Barley flour is fairly versatile and great in quick-breads (think muffins and pancakes). I think I'm about to learn that spelt flour is also very versatile, I just have to remember to use it. Buckwheat flour is good for crepes. In other things, it can impart a blue/grey tinge which is a bit unappetizing. Oat flour is a great addition to cookies, but, probably not worth buying because you can make your own by giving rolled oats a whirl in the blender (though maybe there is more nutritive value in the flour depending on what part of the grain they use/discard. I read that one person blended steel cut oats in the blender and got good results). Millet and rice flour have been the hardest to use. I wouldn't buy either of them again unless I had to make something gluten-free. I don't think that blue cornmeal is anything special compared to yellow. Not surprisingly, it also imparts a blue/grey tinge (C thinks it makes things look "whole grainy").
I'm really excited to keep using my flours and get to the bottom of the remaining bags. The flour isn't getting any younger and I certainly need to use it up by my next 25th birthday. My goal is to use all of the flours and not throw any away, but brown rice flour might be the exception. When it's all said and done, I'm interested to see what flours I pick as pantry staples. So far, rye and barley have made the list. Buckwheat might if for no reason other than crepes, though I have a recipe for barley crepes enqueue and it's possible that they'll be even better than buckwheat crepes. I've also got a lot of cookie recipes enqueue using buckwheat, spelt, barley, and/or rye flours as well as muffins with buckwheat or spelt. I'll be sure to post the links if I find more keepers!

