![]() |
| Thanksgiving 2010: Grandma Marvel taught me to make pie! |
Last November, when Cowboy MD Boyfriend came to St. Louis, we made this pumpkin pie out of a cushaw squash. When I told my mom about the delicious pumpkin pie we made, I explained that I asked the farmers at Soulard Farmers' Market for whatever squash would make the best pie. They all concurred that sugar pumpkins or "pie pumpkins" are not the best choice. They all suggested butternut over pumpkin and other unique varieties over butternut. I told her I had frozen some of the pureed squash and would love to make it into our Thanksgiving pumpkin pie. Her response was something to the effect of "No way, no how. That's not a pumpkin pie. Pumpkin pie is made with pumpkin!" I tried to convince her that it would taste even better than pumpkin pie, but she wouldn't listen (even after I explained that most canned pumpkin is actually made of butternut squash).
This year, I was put in charge of Christmas pies and would be making them by myself. Since I was in charge, I got to use my own recipe for pumpkin pie and chocolate meringue pie and pick my own ingredients. I decided to make the Better Homes and Gardens Pumpkin Pie recipe instead of my grandma's go-to, the Libby's recipe written on the can of pumpkin puree. Since I knew that I wouldn't be able to find a cushaw squash in Madison, I picked up a butternut squash. The night before I planned to bake the pie, I sliced the squash in half, scooped out the seeds, placed it cut-side down onto a foil-lined baking sheet and baked both halves at 350º until the skin was pulling away from the flesh and the flesh was tender enough to be scooped out of the skin. I measured out 1 1/4 cup and refrigerated it overnight. Before making the pie, I pureed the squash in the food processor, then proceeded to make the recipe.
Objective
Make a pumpkin pie with butternut squash. Recipe based on Better Homes and Gardens' Pumpkin Pie with Hazelnut Mousse.
Materials
1 blind-baked pie crust, cooled *read more in the Discussion
1 1/4 cup butternut squash puree
1/3 cup dark brown sugar
1/3 cup light brown sugar
1/4 tsp. salt
1 1/4 tsp. ground ginger
1 1/4 tsp. ground cinnamon
1/8 tsp. ground cloves
2 eggs, lightly beaten
2/3 cup skim milk
1/2 cup heavy whipping cream
1/2 tsp. vanilla
Methods
1. Preheat the oven to 375º.
2. In a small saucepan over medium heat, stir the butternut squash puree, dark and light brown sugars, salt, ginger, cinnamon, and cloves until the sugar dissolves and the puree is hot throughout, about 4-5 minutes. Remove from heat.
3. Whisk together the eggs, skim milk, heavy whipping cream, and vanilla. Gently whisk into the cooling puree. Place the pie crust on a sheet pan and pour the filling into the crust.
4. Bake the pie for 1 hour, then insert a knife into the center of the pie. If the pie is done, the knife will come out clean. If not, continue to bake until it is done cooking. *Note: be sure to monitor the color of the crust as the pie bakes. Once it gets to the shade of brown you prefer, use a pie shield to prevent the crust from burning. You can make your own pie shield by cutting a circle that barely overlaps the filling out of the center of a piece of aluminum foil and setting it over the pie plate.
5. Cool on a wire rack and then refrigerate. Serve with whipped cream (or the hazelnut mousse from the link above).
Results
The pie was more of a deep brown than orange with a deep caramel flavor. (If you use a cushaw squash, it will be caramely and nutty--if you choose a squash at a farmers' market, ask the farmers for their recommendation. They'll be able to tell you how the squash tastes cooked and they'll know what makes the best pie!) While I didn't post the hazelnut mousse recipe, it was a huge hit and all agreed that it could be eaten by the spoonful. Ours was technically almond mousse because I used amaretto, but nevertheless, it was rich, flavorful, and very creamy.
Discussion and Future Directions
Everyone has their own secret to the perfect holiday pie. C's mom makes hers with sweetened condensed milk in place of evaporated milk and she doubles the spices. My grandma always made hers following the recipe on the back of the can exactly as written. While you can get away with the pumpkin pie recipe on the back of the can of pumpkin puree, I think this one is more flavorful. Plus, you can probably make it with things you have on hand since it doesn't require evaporated milk. If you want an extra special holiday dessert, serve with the hazelnut mousse. Hosting for kids? While it doesn't have that much alcohol, you could leave out the liquor and flavor it with vanilla or almond extract if you don't feel comfortable letting kids eat it. While we generally make our chocolate cream pie with meringue, I kind of wish it had been slathered with the mousse, it's that good!
A note on the crust: the original recipe contains a crust recipe that makes three single crust pies. You can absolutely choose to make that crust, but know that it will shrink tremendously (so don't spend time decorating the edges). It's an interesting recipe that uses vinegar and sour cream. The final product is very buttery and flakey. I made the full crust recipe and used the pastry to make a pumpkin, chocolate cream, and a German chocolate pecan pies. If you have a favorite pie crust, feel free to use it!
Supplementary Materials
| The cushaw squash version (that's not the crust recipe from the link) |








